“I’M SORRY ABOUT NKANDLA, AND I WILL PAY”: JACOB ZUMA
President Jacob Zuma has failed to uphold and defend the Constitution as the supreme law of the land, according to SA’s Chief Justice
According to Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng, President Jacob Zuma has failed to uphold and defend the Constitution as the supreme law of the land, during a Constitutional Court ruling on whether Zuma should have paid for non-security upgrades to his Nkandla homestead. The EFF and the DA took Zuma to court in January with the aim of getting the country’s president to pay back some of the R246 million spent on his Nkandla home. The EFF told the court that Zuma had breached his oath of office and constitutional duties by ignoring the Public Protector’s prescribed remedial action on the Nkandla spending. Public Protector Thuli Madonsela stated that Zuma must pay back a portion of the money for upgrades to Nkandla. Mogoeng stated that Zuma’s failure to comply with the Public Protector’s prescribed remedial action – which is binding – was “inconsistent with his obligation to uphold and defend the Constitution as supreme law”. The National Assembly must now determine “the reasonable costs that Zuma must pay for the upgrades”, the court ruled. Mogoeng said the Treasury must report back to the Constitutional Court within 60 days of the order.
“I’m sorry about Nkandla, and I will pay”: Jacob Zuma
President Jacob Zuma apologised to the nation in a live televised address on Friday night, describing a Constitutional Court judgment that found he acted against the Constitution as “helpful”. “The judgment has helped me and my colleagues to reflect deeply on the entire matter. With hindsight, there are many matters that could have been handled differently, and which should never have been allowed to drag on this long, which we deeply regret,” he said. “The matter has caused a lot of frustration and confusion, for which I apologise, on my behalf and on behalf of government.” Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng said that “the National Treasury must determine the reasonable costs of those measures implemented by the department of public works at Zuma’s Nkandla homestead that do not relate to security‚ namely the visitors’ centre‚ the amphitheatre‚ the cattle kraal‚ the chicken run and the swimming pool only”. During his address, Zuma welcomed what he called a” ground-breaking judgement with regards to the powers of the public protector.” “I respect the judgment and will abide by it,” he said. “I have consistently stated that I would pay an amount towards the Nkandla non-security upgrades once this had been determined by the correct authority. The court has ruled on the matter and has devised a mechanism for such determination by the National Treasury.” Though he apologised, Zuma said he never wanted to violate the Constitution. “I also respect the finding that failure to comply with the remedial action taken against me by the Public Protector is inconsistent with the Constitution of the Republic,” Zuma said “I wish to emphasise that I never knowingly or deliberately set out to violate the Constitution, which is the supreme law of the republic.” He says the Constitutional Court’s finding that he failed to comply with Madonsela’s remedial action happened because of a “different approach and different legal advice”. “It all happened in good faith and there was no deliberate effort or intention to subvert the Constitution on my part,” Zuma said. “While correct in law at the time, the approach was subsequently demonstrated to be contrary to the Constitution as stated by the Constitutional Court yesterday [Thursday]. “I had earlier adopted a different approach based on the judgment of the Western Cape High Court. This ruling was subsequently overturned on appeal, and I immediately set out to abide by the ruling of the Supreme Court on this matter. “The intention was not in pursuit of corrupt ends or to use state resources to unduly benefit me and my family.”
He said the Nkandla project brought into focus problems with government’s supply chain mechanisms. “The gross inflation of prices in the Nkandla project is totally unacceptable and should never have been allowed, hence government is improving procurement measures to prevent any future recurrence. “Government also took a conscious decision to clean up the department of public works to ensure that the flouting of supply chain procedures is eradicated and prevented…. Subsequent to this, the department of public works has instituted civil claims against the implicated officials and contractors. “Criminal referrals have also been submitted to the National Prosecuting Authority, while referrals have also been sent to relevant government departments for disciplinary action.”
Zuma ended off his address by saying: “Let us use the judgment to build and further strengthen our democracy”.